
Wycombe Wanderers Football Club PLC has
issued calling notices for two Extraordinary General Meetings
(EGMs) to be held on Saturday 5th July 2008. There is an EGM at
10:00 a.m. for all shareholders of the PLC (i.e. for holders of
both Ordinary and Founder Shares) and a second EGM at 10:10 a.m.
for holders of Founder Shares only. The business of both meetings
is to consider, and if thought appropriate, approve a resolution
to adopt new Articles of Association for the PLC.
The Directors of both Wycombe
Wanderers Supporters Trust and Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust
recommend that the resolutions be approved.
Further, the Directors of both Wycombe Wanderers Supporters Trust
and Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust recommend that members, who
are also Ordinary or Founder Shareholders in the PLC, and who
are unable to attend the meetings in person on the 5th July, return
proxy votes to the PLC. Appropriate forms for proxy votes were
included in the letter from the PLC or may be downloaded from
the links below.
Copies of the following documents can be found below:
1. The covering letter from the Mr. Ivor Beeks, Chairman of the
PLC;
2. The EGM Calling Notices that include the resolutions referred
to above;
3. The proposed Articles of Association;
4. The current Articles of Association; and
5. The forms of proxy distributed by WWFC PLC.
Analysis of the change to
Article 2.9
The current Articles of Association of Wycombe Wanderers Football
Club PLC specify what is to happen in the event of a return of
capital as might happen if the PLC were to be liquidated. The
element of relevance to Trust members is that the Founders Trust
is eligible to direct the distribution of the first £1,320,000
of surplus assets, should there be any, "to the Football
Association Benevolent Fund or to some club or institute in the
High Wycombe area having objects similar to those set out in the
company's Memorandum of Association or to any local charity or
charitable or benevolent institute situate within the said High
Wycombe area." This has the potential to provide some capital
for the formation of a new football club in High Wycombe, if Wycombe
Wanderers Football Club PLC were to be liquidated. Thereafter
the ordinary shareholders are eligible to have the sum paid for
their shares (£1 each) repaid and finally any balance is
to be directed "to the Football Association Benevolent Fund
or to some club or institute in the High Wycombe area having objects
similar to those set out in the company's Memorandum of Association
or to any local charity or charitable or benevolent institute
situate within the said High Wycombe area."
The updated Articles proposed by the PLC in March 2008 modified the wording of these provisions to make a unified Trust the recipient directly of the first £1,320,000 of surplus assets and also the recipient directly of any surplus after the repayment of ordinary shareholders. These were modifications made at the suggestion of the PLC's solicitors and were not something that the Trusts had sought.
The Football Association refused to approve the modified wording. They have specified a revised clause 2.9 that is almost identical to the wording in the current Articles of Association.
From the perspective of a unified Trust, it may have been better to have the modified wording. However, since the Football Association will not approve the modified wording and their required changes leave the parties in the same situation as currently, the revision to clause 2.9 appears to be acceptable.
All the other clauses are identical to those proposed in March 2008.
Since the Football Association has not
approved the updated Articles of Association proposed on March
19th, it is necessary for the PLC to re-run the approval process
for revised Articles of association that incorporate the Football
Association's requirements.
Analysis of the revised Articles
of Association of Wycombe Wanderers Football Club PLC
This analysis is identical to that provided in March 2008 except
for comments on clause 2.9.
The proposed Articles of Association
have been compiled by Olswang, a firm of solicitors, acting on
the instructions of the Board of Wycombe Wanderers Football Club
PLC. If required, members of the Trusts and shareholders of the
PLC should seek independent legal advice on the meaning of the
proposed Articles of Association. If a member has a question on
a specific change then they may raise it with the Trusts via the
contact details provided or with their own legal advisor. Holders
of Ordinary and/or Founder Shares in the PLC may raise the matter
directly with the PLC's Company Secretary, Mr. Keith Allen.
The Trusts have prepared the following comments to assist members
in their analysis of the proposals. The resolutions require that
shareholders approve or otherwise the proposed Articles of Association
in their entirety rather than considering individual new clauses
or changes.
The current and proposed Articles of Association have much in
common although individual clauses in the Articles are ordered
differently.
Unless stated otherwise, the numbering below relates to clauses
in the proposed Articles.
1. In the covering letter, the Chairman states that the Articles
are being updated to address a combination of:
- A better understanding of the needs of a PLC;
- The appropriate aspirations of a modern PLC;
- Changes resulting from the Companies Act 2006; and
- The proposed unification of the Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust
and Wycombe Wanderers Supporters Trust.
The proposed Articles and the changes made to achieve them appear
to be consistent with this stated reasoning.
2. Important components of the original Articles are unchanged:
- The authorised* share capital remains £4,000,000 divided
into 500 Founder Shares and 3,999,500 Ordinary Shares - see Article
2.1;
- No shareholder may own more than 25% of the issued Ordinary
Shares - see Article 2.10;
- The list of rights attached to Founder Shares remains unchanged
- see Article 13.3;
- The rights of Founder Shares can only be altered with the prior
consent of Founder Shareholders - see Article 13.1; and
- The number of directors has a minimum of two and a maximum of
ten unless changed by an ordinary resolution at a general meeting
- see Article 14.
* Out of the authorised share capital, the issued share capital
at 30th June 2007 was £1,260,900 divided into 500 Founder
Shares and 1,260,400 Ordinary Shares.
3. The Companies Act 2006 has required a number of changes, which
include:
- The consent of Founder Shareholders to any changes can only
be given at a separate general meeting of Founder Shareholders
- see Article 13.2. Under the current Articles it can also be
given by the signing of a written resolution by holders not less
than 51% of the nominal value of issued Founder Shares. The Trusts
are told that written resolutions are not permitted for PLCs under
the Companies Act 2006 and hence this possibility is removed from
the proposed Articles.
- Articles 2.4 and 7 give the Company the right to alter its share
capital by Ordinary Resolution. Similar provisions exist in the
current Articles but certain changes are listed as requiring Special
Resolution rather than Ordinary Resolutions. The PLC has been
advised that the Companies Act 2006 requires Ordinary Resolutions
approve these changes.
- Governance via General Meetings, voting by shareholders and
the appointment, retirement and removal of directors has been
updated. The Articles appear appropriate - see Articles 9, 10,
11, 12, 17, 18 and 21.
- Article 21.1 states that "A managing director and a director
holding any other executive office may not be subject to retirement
by rotation.". This clause covers the situation where employees
of the PLC in senior positions are appointed directors. The Trusts
understand that notwithstanding his current position as Managing
Director, Mr. Stephen Hayes will retire by rotation in the normal
manner.
4. The PLC has a better understanding of the details of its Articles
than at the time of its creation in 2004:
- The original intention was and the current practice is that
the Founder Shareholders Trust appoints a director to the PLC.
The proposed Articles specify this rather than referring to the
holders of Founder Shares - see Article 17.1.
5. The proposed unification of Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust
and Wycombe Wanderers Supporters Trust:
- The proposed Articles of Association contain references to Wycombe
Wanderers Trust Limited, the unified Trust, rather than separately
referencing Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust and Wycombe Wanderers
Supporters Trust.
- The proposed Articles of Association provide the unified Trust
with rights and obligations that are as favourable as those enjoyed
currently by the two separate Trusts. Specifically Wycombe Wanderers
Trust Limited may appoint two directors to the Board of the PLC,
one director by right and one providing the unified Trust continues
to hold a minimum of 100,000 Ordinary Shares in the PLC - see
Articles 1.1, 17.1, 17.2 and 17.3. Upon the winding up of the
PLC with positive net assets, the unified Trust would direct the
distribution of the first £1,320,000 of any surplus assets
- see clause 2.9. A Founder Share will be transferred to the unified
Trust in the event of the death or bankruptcy of its holder or
if the holder ceases to hold a season ticket - see Articles 6.1
and 6.2. These are the same conditions as apply to the two separate
Trusts in the current Articles of Association.
6. The proposed Articles of Association include a number of clauses
that might be expected in the Articles of a PLC but which are
absent from the current Articles.
Note: The absence of these matters being addressed in the current
Articles does NOT preclude the directors from taking actions in
these areas as they are legal activities for a PLC:
- The right for directors to be paid remuneration passed by a
resolution of shareholders - see Article 19;
- The right for directors to be paid travelling, hotel and other
expenses properly incurred in the discharging of their duties
- see Article 20;
- The right for directors to provide benefits and pensions to
directors and employees - see Article 22; and
- The right for dividends to be paid subject to the passing of
a resolution declaring the dividend - see Article 27 and the discussion
under item 7 below.
Currently the PLC's directors are unpaid and receive no or de
minimis financial benefits from their roles with the PLC. The
PLC has not made any profit from which to pay a dividend. The
Trusts have been told that there are no current proposals to pay
remuneration to the directors or to pay any dividend. However,
these are all legal activities. If the circumstances of the PLC
were to change, then it may be necessary to employ a full-time
managing director or other executive director, for example, and
it is to be hoped that the PLC generate sufficient profits to
pay a dividend. It is appropriate that the proposed Articles address
these items directly rather than leave them unaddressed.
7. Potentially contentious changes:
There are a small number of changes that might be considered contentious.
These are discussed below but on balance the Directors of the
Trusts do not believe that these are significant enough to recommend
rejecting the proposed Articles of Association.
- Article 2.2 gives the directors the power to issue shares up
to the full amount of the Authorised Share capital for a period
of 5 years from the date of adoption of the Articles. At the PLC
AGM on 1st February 2006, a resolution was passed giving the directors
this right for a period of 5 years, after which it would have
been necessary to seek a further resolution approving this power.
It would have been more consistent with only updating those things
that need updating if the power in Article 2.2 had been limited
to 3 years from 19th March 2008 rather than to 5 years.
- Article 27.4 provides for dividends to be paid in assets as
well as cash. Whilst accepting that it is appropriate that the
Company should be able to pay dividends if it is profitable, the
Trusts believe that dividends should only be payable to the extent
that there is cash available to make the payments. Allowing the
distribution of assets opens up the possibility of assets being
distributed for less than they are worth. This clause has been
introduced at the suggestion of the PLC's solicitors, who are
claiming that it is a standard item for a PLC, rather than at
the request of the PLC's directors. The PLC's directors have agreed
to review whether or not it is desirable to retain this Article
or not and may apply to have it deleted at a future General Meeting.
Since it is possible for the directors to sell assets of the PLC
in the ordinary course of business, it seems that little in the
way of unique risk is introduced by this clause and hence the
Directors of the Trusts do not believe that any such risk is significant
enough to recommend rejecting the proposed Articles of Association.
8. Other changes:
The exact wording of proposed Articles of Association differs
from the existing Articles in many clauses but these differences
are considered by the Trusts either to have the same meaning as
in the current Articles of Association or not to be significant
changes.
In order to adopt the proposed Artciles of Association, shareholders
of the PLC must pass a Special Resolution at an EGM of all shareholders,
Ordinary and Founder Shareholders. A Special Resolution requires
75% of those shareholders voting in person or by proxy to be in
favour for it to pass.
Additionally under Article 13 of the current Articles, holders
of Founder Shares must pass an Ordinary Resolution at a separate
EGM. An Ordinary Resolution requires a simple majority (anything
over 50%) of those shareholders voting in person or by proxy to
be in favour for it to pass.
Both of these meetings are to be held on Saturday 5th July 2008.
Voting the Trusts' Holdings
of Ordinary Shares and Founder Shares
The Supporters Trust and the Founders Trust will vote their holdings
of shares according to the democratic majority wishes of each
Trust's members. For clarity, the two Trusts will vote their shareholdings
separately. The Supporters Trust will vote its holding of 100,000
Ordinary Shares and the Founders Trust will vote its holding of
Founder Shares (137 Founder Shares as at 1st June 2008). Members
may vote on these resolutions by either completing and returning
the paper reponse form mailed to them or completing the electronic
response form below -
see link.
Responses to be received by 6:00 p.m. on Wednesday 2nd July 2008.
The Directors of both Wycombe
Wanderers Supporters Trust and Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust
recommend that the resolutions be approved.
| Francis Glenister | David McGee | |
| Chairman | Chairman | |
| Wycombe Wanderers Supporters Trust | Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust | |
| Email: fg@wwst.org | Email: dm@wwst.org | |
| c/o Wycombe Wanderers Supporters Trust, 1 Allen Drive, Walters Ash, | ||
| High Wycombe, Bucks HP14 4SS | ||
| |
Download
the covering letter for the EGMs on 05/07/2008 as an Adobe Acrobat file Right click on mouse button and select Save Target As ... to download the document |
| |
Download
the notice of the Shareholder EGM as an Adobe Acrobat file Right click on mouse button and select Save Target As ... to download the document |
| |
Download
the notice of the Founder Shareholder General Meeting as an Adobe Acrobat file Right click on mouse button and select Save Target As ... to download the document |
| |
Download
proposed Wycombe Wanderers Football Club PLC Articles of Association as an Adobe Acrobat file Right click on mouse button and select Save Target As ... to download the document |
| |
Download
Wycombe Wanderers Football Club PLC Articles of Association These are the current Articles adopted at 1st February 2006 as an Adobe Acrobat file Right click on mouse button and select Save Target As ... to download the document |
| |
Download
the Form of Proxy for the Shareholder EGM as an Adobe Acrobat file Right click on mouse button and select Save Target As ... to download the document |
| |
Download
the Form of Proxy for the Founder Shareholder EGM as an Adobe Acrobat file Right click on mouse button and select Save Target As ... to download the document |
![]() |
On-line
voting for Members Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust and Wycombe Wanderers Supporters Trust |
| The links below relate to various general meetings of the Trusts and the PLC on the proposal to unify the Trusts | |
![]() |
Wycombe
Wanderers Football Club EGM 19th March 2008 Report on the meetings held on 19th March 2008 to vote on resolutions to adopt revised Articles of Association |
| |
Wycombe
Wanderers Supporters Trust SGM 27th February 2008 Report on the meeting held on 27th February 2008 to vote on an Ordinary Resolution required to unify the two Trust |
| |
Wycombe
Wanderers Founders Trust and Supporters Trust Report on the meetings held on 7th February 2008 to vote on measures to unify the two Trusts |
| |
Wycombe
Wanderers Founders Trust and Supporters Trust Timetable of meetings required to unify the two Trust |
| |
Wycombe
Wanderers Founders Trust and Supporters Trust Report on the joint meeting held on 23rd January 2008 to receive detailed proposals regarding a unification of the two Trusts |
| |
Wycombe
Wanderers Founders Trust and Supporters Trust Report on the initial meeting held 28th June 2007 to discuss the unification of the two Trusts |
![]() |
Return to the News page on the Trust |
![]() |
*** Join
the Supporters Trust *** Click here for link to application details |
![]() |
Founders
Trust The Board of Wycombe Wanderers Supporters Trust urges everyone who is eligible to join Wycombe Wanderers Founders Trust in addition to joining the Supporters Trust - see here for links between the two Trusts |
| Shopping
On-line at Amazon.co.uk via this link helps the Supporters Trust at no extra cost to you |
|
| |
|
| |
Information Page on the Supporters Trust |
| |
Supporters Trust Home Page |